Back

Google Warns: URL Parameters Create Crawl Issues

Last updated on

Gary Illyes, an analyst at Google, recently emphasized a significant challenge for web crawlers: URL parameters.

In a recent episode of Google’s Search Off The Record podcast, Illyes detailed how these parameters can lead to an infinite number of URLs for the same page, resulting in crawl inefficiencies.

He delved into the technical implications, the impact on SEO, and potential solutions, while also reflecting on Google’s previous strategies and suggesting possible future improvements.

This information is particularly important for large websites and e-commerce platforms.

The Infinite URL Problem

Illyes pointed out that URL parameters can generate what is essentially an infinite number of URLs for a single page.

He elaborates:

“Technically, you can append an almost infinite—well, effectively infinite—number of parameters to any URL, and the server will simply disregard those that don’t change the response.”

This poses a challenge for search engine crawlers.

Even though these variations may lead to the same content, crawlers cannot determine this without visiting each URL. As a result, this can lead to inefficient crawl resource usage and potential indexing problems.

E-commerce Sites Most Affected

This issue is particularly common on e-commerce websites, where URL parameters are frequently used to track, filter, and sort products.

For example, a single product page might have several URL variations to account for different color options, sizes, or referral sources.

Illyes noted:

“Since you can simply add URL parameters, it complicates everything during the crawling process. When you’re crawling properly by ‘following links,’ everything becomes significantly more complex.”

Historical Context

Google has been dealing with this challenge for years. Previously, they provided a URL Parameters tool in Search Console, allowing webmasters to specify which parameters were essential and which could be ignored.

However, this tool was discontinued in 2022, raising concerns among SEOs about how to effectively manage this issue moving forward.

Potential Solutions

Although Illyes didn’t provide a concrete solution, he hinted at possible strategies:

Google is considering ways to manage URL parameters, possibly by creating algorithms to detect redundant URLs. Illyes suggested that clearer communication from website owners about their URL structure could be beneficial. “We might advise them to use a specific method to block that URL space,” he remarked.

He also mentioned the potential for greater use of robots.txt files to guide crawlers, noting, “Robots.txt is surprisingly flexible in what it can achieve.”

Implications For SEO

This discussion carries several important implications for SEO:

  • Canonical Tags: Implementing canonical tags can assist Google in identifying which version of a URL should be treated as the primary one.
  • Crawl Budget: For large websites, effectively managing URL parameters can help conserve crawl budget, ensuring that critical pages are crawled and indexed.
  • Site Architecture: Developers may need to rethink their URL structures, especially on large e-commerce sites with numerous product variations.
  • Faceted Navigation: E-commerce sites using faceted navigation should be aware of how it affects URL structure and crawlability.

Original news from SearchEngineJournal